Why is practicing slowly so unpopular?

There appears to be a stigma attached to parceling out a brand new piece in deliberately slow tempo, where a player threads through separate lines with a commitment to expression framed by an ultra-relaxed singing pulse. In the best realization of such immersion, the music becomes magnified to a new level of awareness, albeit in the incipient learning stage. (Fingering decisions are made; phrases undergo slow motion contouring, and a deep key/weight transferred relationship to the notes is explored, avoiding a top of the keys haphazard glide.)

Such slow but engaged practicing as described, sets a foundation for added layers of learning on progressively deeper levels.

Yet students who are asked to pull back from an advanced tempo that is racing out of their control will resist the push back to a near heart-stopping pace. Or at least they will re-try a separate hand reading at the tempo set by the teacher only to deviate from the agreed upon "beat," as if the mentor would hardly notice.

Face the music, practicing at a snail's pace, but preserving the player's "high" inside a MAGNIFIED musical bubble, still attaches a Western cultural taboo allied to our fast-paced existence with its built-in upward MOBILITY frenzy. ("Getting there fast is half the fun," blasted at fever pitch in carry-over-to-life auto advertising is pervasive!)

Add in cell phones grunting out instant message alerts at fever pitch amidst unwanted calls interrupting piano lessons, and it's no wonder that peace of mind needed to inhabit a retrograde inversion of time is a foreign and ill-timed request.

Still I refuse to surrender my commitment to time-honored teaching that is in defiance of a Beat the Clock, 1950's era mantra. As antidote to the culture of cramming, crowding, and herding notes in a cadential stampede, I underscore my own SLOWED down approach to all my music from Bach to Blues.

"If I can practice my pieces slowly, so can you."

I'll admit that there's a bit of guilt sandwiched into my haughty, authoritarian push back, but it works, at least for 15-minute chunks, before an iPhone breaks the mood of a higher Power tempo-suspended intervention.

By example, I will rehash one of my classic learning journeys and how it advanced from a heightened back tempo approach to a smooth and satisfying outpouring. That usually gets my adult brood going, at least for the time being.

***

(Below is a J.S. Bach Prelude that I allowed months to grow from carefully spaced-out seeding to its eventual maturation.)

***

An Adult Student exemplifies slow practicing in Turk's "Happiness"

The steady progress made over time:

Original Content: Why is practicing slowly so unpopular?